I read Malinda Lo's debut novel on the advice of one Heather Hogan. I don't think I've ever made a better whim decision. I read Ash on the bus home the day I got it from my library. I nearly missed my stop, because I got utterly lost. Ash, Kaisa, Sidhean. I was as as Ash, whether to follow the wishful thinking of childhood, turned into a dream like reality of a young women. Or the reality of a young women seeming more dream like than anything in her life before. Ash is reminiscent of Cinderella. Every word reminded me of Ever After, [Which I love. Really.] from a sensual point of view. The description of the forest, and the Soul's Night Ball echo of the movie, but stand on their own at the same time. The forest is lush. The Ball is confusing, and overwhelming, and fabulous. Quinn House is dark, dank, and depressing when Lady Isobel is there, and transformed when Kaisa comes a calling to something homely.
And the interesting thing that Lo did is that is wishing. Wishing for something different. For her mother back. For her father. To be back in Rook Kill. But more than anything to be away from her wicked stepmother and detestable stepsisters.
Ana is the mildly beautiful and perpetually spoiled older sister to Clara, the shy-by-force dreamer. Ana is a power hungry young girl in search of a powerful, but more importantly rich, husband. Lady Isobel continually caters to her needy daughter, and Clara plays the part of the dutiful sibling who is always going to be the door mat.
But, Ana, Clara, and Lady Isobel are background pieces and catalysts all at once. They push all of Ash's buttons in all the wrong ways, while Kaisa and Sidhean push her buttons in the right ways. First we meet Sidhean. The ethereal fairy that will do near anything to keep Ash happy and safe, yet constantly distant and cold. Kaisa is the yin to Sidheans yang. Where Sidhean is distant, Kaisa begins to seek Ash out. When Sidhean is cold, Kaisa is inviting. Kaisa is entirely human, and yet Ash has a harder time rationalizing Kaisa's interest in her than rationalizing Sidheans very existance.
"Ash laughed thinly. 'Content?' she repeated, and she heard the bitterness in her voice. 'I am a servant...' She trailed off, feeling uncomfortable; had the huntress not just sent her servant away to serve her? The difference hand never bothered her before; in the wood, when they were alone, she could imagine that they were at the same level. But after the hunt and the ball..."
-Malinda Lo, Ash.
Everything I wanted to happen in Ash, did. But it wasn't predictable. Ash was enjoyable, and engaging. I do think that Lo held back. I think she could have gone a step further. That she was reigning herself in on purpose. I look forward to her next book, Huntress, to see if she exceeds my expectations.
Lo gets a 4.5 out of 5. I liked it and want more.